I (Not AI) Will Always Write Your Ceremonies

I’ll probably write at least some of your ceremony using one of these three fountain pens.

Conversations about AI are everywhere at the moment. This transformational new technology, like the others that preceded it, has brought with it a vast range of uses, questions, ethical stances, fears, and hopes.

This blog post isn’t really going to grapple with any of those issues. All I really need to say is this: I will never use AI to write your ceremony.

AI might allow me to write your ceremony more quickly. It might offer a ceremony flow or structure that I haven’t thought of, or suggest a ritual that hadn’t occurred to me. It might synthesize the available information about ritual and ceremony in a way that guides me in a new direction.

I’m still not going to use it. I’m not saying that I think it’s wrong for a celebrant to use AI in these ways. Each of us is going to have to establish our own criteria regarding whether and how to use this technology. What I’m saying is that my own personal criteria mean that I am not going to use it.

Why? Because fundamentally, I feel that this work is sacred work. And I don’t think sacred work can be done by anything other than the hearts and minds and hands of human beings.* I think this work deserves human effort, human emotion, and human vulnerability.

I am still going to research your ceremony thoroughly. I am still going to learn as much as I can about creating ritual and ceremony - because I love learning about these things, and because my passion for that learning is part of what drew me to celebrancy in the first place. I am going to draw on my training, the expertise of my colleagues, the vast scope of historical and contemporary approaches to ceremony, and my own creativity. I will write the very best ceremony I can write, using all of the skills available to me. The words that I speak at your ceremony will be words that came out of a human mind and heart. Like all such creations, they will sometimes be imperfect. They may (will) take me longer to write than they would take a large language model to generate. I am still going to write every word of them myself. Whoever it is we are honouring, they are a human being, and human beings will create the ceremony that lays them to rest.

* “Sacred” is a big, loaded word. It probably deserves its own post, but what I mean by it here is that this is work that is inextricable from the most fundamental of human concerns: meaning, love, death, and life. Basically, whatever the broadest, most pluralistic, least dogmatic, most inclusive version of that word you can imagine is, that’s what I mean.

Next
Next

Plants of the crossroads